SEO Cost & ROI

How to Choose an SEO Agency: Questions to Ask, Red Flags and a Scorecard

The questions to ask on the call, the red flags to walk away from, what agencies charge, and a scorecard to compare proposals side by side.

By
Andrés Esquivel
Updated
November 17, 2026
7
min read
Providers on a monthly retainer
78.2%
Average agency retainer
$3,209
Clicks when an AI summary shows
8%
A stack of agency proposals with some answers flagged, pointing to a scorecard with weighted bars

To choose an SEO agency, first decide what SEO has to produce for your business, then compare agencies on who does the work, proof from companies like yours, how they tie SEO to pipeline, whether they handle AI search, and their contract terms. Ask every agency the same questions and score the answers side by side.

In short
  • Decide the goal, budget and timeline before the first call, so every agency answers the same brief.
  • Ask who will work on your account and whether they implement changes or only send reports.
  • Walk away from guaranteed rankings, secrecy about methods and long lock-in contracts.
  • Score each proposal on the same seven criteria and compare totals, not sales pitches.
Providers on a monthly retainer
78.2%
of SEO providers charge a monthly retainer (Ahrefs pricing survey of 439 providers, updated 2024)
Average agency retainer
$3,209
average monthly retainer for SEO agencies, Ahrefs' estimate from its pricing survey (2024)
Clicks when an AI summary shows
8%
of Google visits with an AI summary ended in a click on a result, vs 15% without one (Pew Research Center, 2025)

What Should You Decide Before You Talk to Agencies?

Agencies answer the brief they are given. If the brief is vague, every proposal looks different and none can be compared. Settle four things first.

  • The goal. Leads, pipeline or revenue from organic search, not rankings or traffic on their own.
  • The budget. A monthly range you can hold for at least six months.
  • Your own capacity. Who on your team can approve content and make site changes, and how fast. If you are still deciding whether to hire at all, compare in-house SEO vs an agency.
  • The timeline. When leadership expects to see progress, and what counts as progress. See how long SEO takes for realistic milestones.

Send the same one-page brief to every agency on your shortlist.

What Should You Ask an SEO Agency on the Call?

These ten questions separate agencies that do the work from agencies that sell it. The first group comes from Google's own advice on hiring an SEO; the rest come from what buyers tell us went wrong with a previous agency.

QuestionA good answerA red flag
Can you show results from companies like ours?Named clients, numbers and dates, in your industry or business modelLogos only, or results with no dates
Who will work on our account?Named people, their seniority and hours per monthYou only ever meet the sales team
Do you implement changes or only recommend them?They make the changes on your site, or work directly with your developerA long audit and a list of tasks for your team
What results do you expect, and by when?A range, the assumptions behind it and milestones for day 30, 60 and 90A guaranteed position or traffic number
How do you measure success?Leads and pipeline from organic search, with rankings as a supporting signalRankings and traffic only
Do you follow Google Search Essentials?Yes, and they explain how they earn links and mentionsVague talk about link packages or networks
How do you handle AI search?They track what ChatGPT, Gemini and AI Overviews say about you and show the methodIt is an add-on, or they dismiss it
What does the first 90 days look like?A written plan: fixes first, then content, then authorityA generic onboarding deck
What do we own if we leave?All content, accounts, data and reports stay with youThe agency owns the accounts or the content
What are the contract terms?Month to month or a short term with a clear notice periodA 12-month lock-in with no exit

What Are the Red Flags When Hiring an SEO Agency?

Google's guidance is blunt: "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." It also warns against firms that email you out of the blue, are secretive about what they do, or talk about link schemes. For an audit, an agency needs read access to Google Search Console and nothing more.

Three more come up again and again when companies switch agencies: reports with no implementation, a senior team in the sales call and juniors on the account, and a long contract with no way out.

Six red flags: guaranteed number one rankings, reports with no implementation, senior sales and junior delivery, 12-month lock-in with no exit, secrecy about methods or links, reporting rankings and not leads
Six red flags to check for before you sign.

How Do You Judge an Agency's Proof?

Case studies are easy to dress up. Check four things in each one.

  • A named company. Anonymous results cannot be checked.
  • Numbers with dates. A percentage with no baseline and no time frame says nothing.
  • A business like yours. A local service result does not predict a B2B SaaS result.
  • Business outcomes. Leads, demos or revenue, not only traffic.

Then ask for a reference call with one of those clients, and ask the client who did the work.

Check whether the agency ranks for its own services. Search for what they sell, and ask an AI assistant to recommend agencies like them. An agency that cannot be found is asking you to trust a method it has not proven on itself.

What Does an SEO Agency Cost, and What Terms Should You Accept?

Most SEO is sold as a monthly retainer. In Ahrefs' survey of 439 SEO providers, 78.2% charged a retainer, agencies averaged about $3,209 a month, and the most common band across all providers was $501 to $1,000. The spread is wide because scope is wide: a retainer that covers technical fixes, content and reporting is not the same product as a monthly report.

$3,209
Ahrefs · SEO pricing survey, updated 2024
Average monthly retainer among SEO agencies, estimated from 439 survey responses. Compare what a proposal includes before you compare its price.

Compare proposals line by line: what is done each month, who does it and what you receive. Our SEO pricing page explains the common pricing models and how to compare proposals. On terms, prefer month to month or a short initial term, a notice period in writing, and ownership of everything produced.

Can the Agency Handle AI Search Too?

Buyers now ask ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity for a shortlist before they search Google, and Google answers many questions itself. Pew Research Center found that users clicked a result in 8% of visits when an AI summary appeared, against 15% without one. An agency that only reports rankings is measuring part of the picture.

Ask each agency to show how it gets pages cited in AI answers and how it measures AI visibility. If the term is new to you, start with what answer engine optimization is. A specialist AEO agency should run this as part of SEO, not as a separate product.

The SEO Agency Scorecard

Score every agency out of 100 on the same seven criteria. The weights reflect what most often decides whether an engagement works: who does the work and whether there is proof.

Agency scorecard out of 100 points: who does the work and do they implement 20, proof with similar companies 20, strategy tied to pipeline 15, AI search ability 15, pricing and contract terms 10, reporting 10, communication 10
The scorecard: seven criteria, 100 points.
CriterionPointsWhat earns full marks
Who does the work, and do they implement20Named senior people who make the changes themselves
Proof with similar companies20Named, dated results in your industry, plus a reference call
Strategy tied to pipeline15A plan built around the searches your buyers make before they buy
AI search ability15A method for citations and a way to measure them
Pricing and contract terms10Clear scope, no long lock-in, you own the work
Reporting10Leads and pipeline first, in a report leadership can read
Communication10A named contact, a regular call and fast answers

Not sure how your current program would score? An independent SEO audit gives you a second opinion, and SEO consulting turns it into a 90-day roadmap.

The Bottom Line

Choosing an SEO agency comes down to evidence: who does the work, what they have done for companies like yours, and whether they can tie it to leads. Send one brief, ask the same ten questions, and let the scorecard decide.

If you are weighing whether SEO still pays off at all, read Is SEO dead? first. Once you have signed, use is your SEO agency working? and SEO reporting for leadership to review the work, and SEO ROI to measure the return. To see where your site stands today, start with a free SEO report.

FAQ

What does an SEO agency cost per month?

Most providers charge a monthly retainer. In Ahrefs' survey of 439 SEO providers, agencies averaged about $3,209 a month, and the most common band across all providers was $501 to $1,000. Price follows scope, so compare what each proposal includes, not only the total.

How long before an SEO agency shows results?

Expect technical and on-page fixes in the first weeks and measurable movement in rankings and leads over several months. Ask each agency what will be done by day 30, 60 and 90 and how progress will be reported.

Should we hire in-house or use an SEO agency?

An agency gives you a full team at once; an in-house hire gives you one person with deep company knowledge. Many growth-stage companies start with an agency that implements, then hire in-house once the program is proven.

Can ChatGPT replace an SEO agency?

No. AI tools speed up research and drafting, but they do not fix your site, earn mentions or take responsibility for results. A good agency uses AI tools and still does the implementation.

5.0 on Clutch · 350+ companies served
Get a Free SEO Report.
A senior strategist reviews your site and walks you through it on a 30-minute call. No sales pitch, and you keep the report either way. It includes:
Technical review
AI search readiness score
30-minute review call
Strategy roadmap
Get my free SEO report
Sources
Andrés Esquivel
Andrés Esquivel
Founder & Chief Strategist, Digital Socios

Andrés founded Digital Socios and Glued and leads Digital Socios' AI search work. He has spent 8+ years building websites and user experiences for brands like Nestlé, Vital Proteins and Pfizer.

Andrés Esquivel on LinkedIn
5.0 on Clutch · 350+ companies served

See Where You Stand in Google and AI Search.

■ Technical SEO■ Content■ AI search■ Reporting
Free SEO report
Get a Free SEO Report
A technical review of your site and your AI search readiness, with every fix ranked by revenue impact.
Get my free SEO report
Strategy call
Talk to a Strategist
A 30-minute working session with a senior strategist about your site and your goals. Not a sales call.
Get in touch