SEO Cost & ROI

Is Your SEO Agency Working? How to Review It

Eight checks, the numbers that matter at month 3, 6 and 12, and how to tell slow results from no results before you renew.

By
Andrés Esquivel
Updated
November 17, 2026
6
min read
Google's estimate for SEO results
4 to 12 mo
Clicks when an AI summary shows
8%
Average agency retainer per month
$3,209
An agency report with some items flagged on the left, connected to a chart of real results on the right

Your SEO agency is working if you can see changes going live on your site, the early signals are moving, and leads from non-branded organic search are growing. Review it on three things: the work done, the results by stage, and whether you could explain to your CEO what you are paying for. If any of the three is blank, ask questions before you renew.

In short
  • Judge the first 90 days by work done, months 3 to 6 by early signals, and month 12 by leads.
  • Split branded from non-branded traffic. Growth in branded search alone is not the agency's result.
  • Falling traffic is not always failure: AI summaries cut clicks even when rankings hold.
  • Reports that show rankings but never leads are the clearest warning sign.
  • If you are unsure, get an independent audit before you decide to stay or switch.
Google's estimate for SEO results
4 to 12 mo
the time SEOs need to implement improvements and then see potential benefit, according to Google's Maile Ohye (2017)
Clicks when an AI summary shows
8%
of Google visits with an AI summary ended in a click on a result, vs 15% without one (Pew Research Center, 2025)
Average agency retainer per month
$3,209
average monthly retainer for SEO agencies, Ahrefs' estimate from its pricing survey of 439 providers (2024)

How Do You Know If Your SEO Agency Is Working?

Ask three questions. What changed on our site this quarter? Which numbers moved because of it? Could I explain to our CEO what we are paying for? A working agency makes all three easy to answer. If you cannot answer them from the reports you receive, that is a finding in itself.

The rest of this guide turns those questions into a review you can run in an afternoon, with access to Google Search Console, Google Analytics 4 and your last three agency reports.

The Eight Checks

Eight checks: changes went live this quarter, leads from organic search are tracked, non-branded clicks are growing, rankings improved on buyer searches, you know who works on your account, reports explain what happens next, AI visibility is being measured, you own the accounts, content and data
Eight checks for your agency review.
CheckWhere to lookA good sign
Changes went live this quarterYour site, the agency's change logA dated list of pages fixed, rewritten or published
Organic leads are trackedGA4 key eventsForm submissions and calls are recorded by channel
Non-branded clicks are growingSearch Console, queries without your brand nameAn upward trend over six months
Rankings improved on buyer searchesSearch Console or the rank reportGains on service and comparison terms, not only blog topics
You know who does the workYour last three callsThe same named people, who know your business
Reports explain what is nextThe monthly reportA short plan for next month tied to results
AI visibility is measuredThe report, or askA set of buyer questions tracked in AI assistants
You own everythingAccount settings, the contractAnalytics, Search Console, content and data are in your name

Six or more good signs: the engagement is healthy. Three to five: raise the gaps at your next call and set a date to review again. Two or fewer: get a second opinion.

What Should You See at Month 3, 6 and 12?

SEO is slow by nature. Google's own estimate is four months to a year to implement improvements and see the benefit. That makes it easy for a poor agency to say results are coming. The answer is to judge each stage by what should exist at that stage.

What good looks like: month 3 work is visible, month 6 signals are moving, month 12 leads have grown
What good looks like at each stage.
  • Month 3: work is visible. Technical fixes are live, your main service pages have been rewritten, and tracking is in place. You have seen the plan.
  • Month 6: signals are moving. Impressions, rankings on buyer searches and non-branded clicks are up against the starting point.
  • Month 12: leads have grown. Leads and pipeline from organic search are above where you began, and the agency can show which work produced them.

For more detail on each stage, see how long SEO takes.

Why Does the Branded Split Matter?

Organic traffic includes people who typed your company name. They were going to find you anyway. If your reports show organic growth, check how much of it is branded.

  1. Open Google Search Console and go to the Performance report.
  2. Filter queries to those that contain your brand name. Note clicks for the last six months.
  3. Change the filter to queries that do not contain your brand name. Note the same figure.
  4. Compare both with the six months before.

Growth in non-branded clicks is the agency reaching new buyers. Growth in branded clicks alone usually reflects your sales, ads, events or PR.

Ask for the split in every report. A good agency shows branded and non-branded results separately without being asked. It is the simplest test of honest reporting.

Is Falling Traffic Always the Agency's Fault?

No. Search itself has changed. Pew Research Center found that Google users clicked a result in 8% of visits when an AI summary appeared, against 15% without one. Informational pages can hold their rankings and still lose clicks.

8%
Pew Research Center · March 2025 data
Share of Google visits with an AI summary that ended in a click on a result, against 15% without one. Traffic can fall while the agency is doing its job.

What matters is whether your agency saw it, explained it and adjusted. A working agency will have:

  • Shown you which pages lost clicks to AI answers and which lost rankings.
  • Shifted effort toward the searches buyers make close to a decision.
  • Started tracking whether AI assistants mention you. See how to measure AI visibility.

An agency that reports the drop without an explanation, or does not mention AI search at all, has not kept up. For the wider picture, read Is SEO dead?

What Are the Warning Signs?

  • Reports with rankings and no leads. Rankings are a means. If nobody can connect them to enquiries, nobody is managing to the goal.
  • Recommendations nobody implements. A list of tasks sent to your team each month is advice, not SEO.
  • A changing cast. New account managers every quarter who ask what your company does.
  • Vague link building. Google warns against SEOs who are secretive about what they do or who talk about link schemes.
  • Accounts you cannot access. Analytics or Search Console set up in the agency's name.
  • Pressure to extend. A long renewal offered just as you start asking questions.

What Should You Do Next?

  1. Raise it directly. Share your review and ask for a 90-day plan with specific work and expected signals.
  2. Set a checkpoint. Agree what you will see in 90 days, in writing.
  3. Get a second opinion. An independent SEO audit tells you whether the problem is the agency, the site or the market.
  4. Decide. If the checkpoint is missed, plan the move. Our guide on how to switch SEO agencies covers how to do it without losing rankings.

The Bottom Line

A working SEO agency leaves evidence: changes on your site, signals that move in the right order, and leads you can trace. Slow is normal. Invisible is not. Run the eight checks, split branded from non-branded, and judge each stage by what should exist by then.

If you want an outside view of where your program stands, start with a free SEO report. To put the results in front of leadership, see how to measure SEO ROI.

FAQ

How long should I give an SEO agency before judging results?

Judge the work from the first month and the results by stage. By month 3 you should see changes live, by month 6 early signals moving, and by month 12 more leads from organic search. Google's own estimate for SEO results is four months to a year.

What should an SEO agency report every month?

What was done, what moved, and what happens next. That means a list of changes made, leads and non-branded clicks from organic search, rankings on buyer searches, and a short plan for the coming month.

My traffic dropped. Should I fire my SEO agency?

Not on that alone. AI summaries reduce clicks even when rankings hold. Check whether rankings, non-branded clicks on buyer searches and leads also fell, and whether the agency explained the change. If they did not notice or cannot explain it, that is the problem.

Can I get a second opinion without telling my agency?

Yes. An independent audit only needs read access to Google Search Console and analytics, which you control. It is a normal step before a renewal.

5.0 on Clutch · 350+ companies served
Get a Free SEO Report.
A senior strategist reviews your site and walks you through it on a 30-minute call. No sales pitch, and you keep the report either way. It includes:
Technical review
AI search readiness score
30-minute review call
Strategy roadmap
Get my free SEO report
Sources
Andrés Esquivel
Andrés Esquivel
Founder & Chief Strategist, Digital Socios

Andrés founded Digital Socios and Glued and leads Digital Socios' AI search work. He has spent 8+ years building websites and user experiences for brands like Nestlé, Vital Proteins and Pfizer.

Andrés Esquivel on LinkedIn
5.0 on Clutch · 350+ companies served

See Where You Stand in Google and AI Search.

■ Technical SEO■ Content■ AI search■ Reporting
Free SEO report
Get a Free SEO Report
A technical review of your site and your AI search readiness, with every fix ranked by revenue impact.
Get my free SEO report
Strategy call
Talk to a Strategist
A 30-minute working session with a senior strategist about your site and your goals. Not a sales call.
Get in touch